The notion of investing varies a lot between generations.
- The older folks prefer Real Estate Investing.
- And the younger ones prefer Stock Market Investing.
But is one better than the other?
No, they both serve their own purposes. - Depends on what stage of investing you are in.
- Do you need cash flows or growth?
- Do you need to be diversified?
And that’s what we will take a look at today.
1. Returns:
Equity Markets (Nifty as an example) gives around 11-12% CAGR over a 10-20 year period.
Now if you look at Real Estate Markets over a long period it gives relatively lower returns (~3-4%).
Does this make real estate a bad investment?
NO.
- You are not understanding the impact of Black and White Money here.
- The actual return would be much higher, and more importantly, this is just the Appreciation. You are not considering Rental Yield.
- We will discuss more about this later.
- But the point is your returns on Real Estate are not what official data shows us, there is more to the story.
2. There is also a concept of Re-investment risk, which is lesser in Real Estate
- Real Estate lets you stick to your assets, and this becomes specifically easier if you are planning to invest for your kids.
- As long as it brings in good rent, you don’t need to think of selling or reinvesting your property.
- The idea here is that different Asset classes have different purposes.
- Real Estate is more about stability and the Stock Market is about liquidity and growth.
3. All Asset classes go through cycles.
- They go through an up-phase, down-phase, and consolidation phase.
- Real Estate normally has a longer cycle.
- Equity Markets go through a lot of volatility.
But what's important here is that if you are diversified, you get to make good decisions at bad times.
A smart investor will understand and explore both asset classes, and maintain a diversified portfolio.
- Some people will make money in both markets,
- And some people will lose money in both markets.
What you need to do is take time out to learn and apply.
- The idea is that during bad times in Equity Markets, you have consistent cashflows.
- And during bad phases of the Real Estate Market, your Equity Portfolio continues to grow.
The biggest issue is the Opaqueness in the Real Estate Market.
Source
- Akshat Shrivastava 30 days Newsletter.